Home › I'm Not That Girl I'm Not That Girl · Wicked: For Good · 2024 The singer tells herself not to idealize a potential romance, accepting that she is not the perfect, idealized partner the object of her affection desires. MoodLonging SungTo one's own heart LanguageEnglish Other versions I'm Not That Girl (Reprise) · Wicked: For Good · 2025 Songs like I'm Not That Girl What Is This Feeling? · 2024 Lagta nahi Dil · 2026 Second Nature Bon Iver · 2021 Anti-Hero Taylor Swift · Midnights · 2022 That’s It Yung Lean · 2026 The Girl In The Bubble · Wicked: For Good More songs like I'm Not That Girl ›